“Knowing truth is important. Right and wrong are truth, not feelings. And they are the same for everyone. Our creator is the source of the rules for right and wrong and they come from his character.”
(Member of the public library advisory board)
Citizens appointed by local government are policing which books held in the public library can be read by children. The local newspaper documents offending titles, along with the censor’s comments about each book. Reported summaries and excerpts of comments follow.
“Sex Is a Funny Word,” by authors Fiona Smyth and Cory Silverberg “‘Introduce[s] ideas about sexuality, transgenderism and sexual activity… Would ‘cause confusion for children who read it and put sexual ideas that they are not mature enough to handle.’”
“Making a Baby,” by authors Rachel Greener and Clare Owen “…Illustrations of White and racially mixed gay, lesbian and straight couples with children… ‘The pictures of naked adults and the sex act are not age appropriate for children….’”
“Queer: The Ultimate LGBTQ Guide for Teens,” by authors Kathy Belge and Marke Bieschke “If a teen is confused about their sexuality (the book) may cause them to embrace a lifestyle they may regret… A public library should… refrain from opening doors to children that should not be opened.”
“Red: A Crayon’s Story,” by author Michael Hall “Ideas of transgenderism [are] damaging… ‘It could twist the cognitive learning development in a child.’
“Teens and LGBT Issues,” by author Christine Wilcox “‘…Boys who are sexually abused by men want to get rid of their genitalia because in their mind they feel like if their genitalia is gone they won’t be sexually abused again… Girls who are sexually abused often want to become boys as a way to show power so they will be feared… Why would we want this deviant behavior to mold and shape the minds of our youth?’”
(Tamara Diaz, “3 city approved library board members filed LGBTQ book complaints,” http://www.victoriaadvocate.com, 9-22-22)
Working head of state one day, gone the next. Sic transit gloria. An adoring contingent of Great Britain has lately felt its feelings in splendid public fashion for a queen whose reign exceeded average life expectancy in most of the world.
Shed of mourning now, the kingdom is abuzz over something known as the quasi-quatrain and a mysterious “physical event” connected to it.
We who closely follow prosodic events in the UK are keen to know more about a thing conjecture dictates plausibly to be some cuadri-partite stanzaic verse scheme, formally crippled by design, perhaps, in the manner of the Spanish pie quebrado, or “broken foot,” conceivably an epic form for singing exploits of the elderly new monarch, easily supposed to have been culled from some ancient manuscript lodged in a rustic chapel nestled in the Pennines, and which ostensibly is garnering excited comment on this auspicious dawning of the second Carolean epoch.
Two self-portraits by Frank Auerbach painted during the pandemic. Photograph: Frank Auerbach.
“In his view, painting and drawing are exactly the same difficulty and take roughly as long as each other.”
(William Feaver, art critic and one of Auerbach’s regular sitters)
Asked whether he has learned something new about his face, [Auerbach] said he has never thought in verbal, emotional or psychological terms about his subjects as that “undermines what one is doing.”
I’m simply trying to use the subject to make an image of my impression of it.”
(Frank Auerbach)
Auerbach’s commentary on his practice strikes me as state-of-the-art language concerning what picture making can be about.
(Dalya Alberge, “Frank Auerbach: how artist drew himself for Covid ‘plague years’ drawings,” theguardian.com, 9-18-22)
Opposite a vaguely anthropomorphic shape etched on the menhir’s side lies the squiggle. Angel Castaño, a philologist, believes it depicts the contours of the Tagus River before the hydroelectric dam was built. “The menhir may be the oldest realistic map in the world,” he says.
Primitiva Bueno Ramírez, an archaeologist, demurs. “The hypothesis of a map is based on a pareidolia,” she says. Dr. Bueno notes that the geometric squiggle resembles “twisty markings” widely found in European megalithic art. Her conclusion: It’s a snake.
“Pareidolia”: the tendency for perception to impose a meaningful interpretation on an ambiguous visual pattern.
A megalithic archaeological site has been exposed by drought in Spain. Some 2,000 years older than Stonehenge, the Bronze Age sepulcher was deliberately flooded in 1963 as part of a rural development project.
Like the skeleton of an extinct sea monster, the Dolmen of Guadalperal has resurfaced from the depths of the Valdecañas reservoir in western Spain…
No, no, no, Franz Lidz. Not “extinct,” not the “sea,” not a “monster.” The great-great-grandmother of the Anglian pile is alive and well in Iberia. She has shrugged off her manmade puddle to remind men that man’s a speck on the planet, a booger in its nostrils, flicked away sooner than not, who knows for the better.
Also, to whisper to the wind, “Friend, hard weather’s ahead.”
Free expression isn’t just a feature of democracy; it is a necessary prerequisite.
(Editorial Board, “Censorship Is the Refuge of the Weak,” New York Times, 9-10-22)
No big deal. Just a nicety of style, a peccadillo none but the persnickety rhetorician besotted with the jots and tittles of messaging has the effrontery to bust a potshot on. But the New York Times, a bastion of style and clarity, well merits being held to high account.
With the phrase necessary prerequisite, the journal steps in the same puddle of fudge that slathers our palaver with shambling redundancies such as free gifts and viable alternatives. If not free, not a gift; if not viable, not an alternative; if not necessary, not a prerequisite.
The point remains: Clear, true speech is the hill that democracy must choose to die on.
“We have to change our mentality so that eating a barbecued entrecôte is no longer a symbol of virility… If you want to resolve the climate crisis, you have to reduce meat consumption, and that’s not going to happen so long as masculinity is constructed around meat…” (Sandrine Rousseau, French Green Party MP)
“Stop this madness!”… “That’s enough of accusing our boys of everything!” (Eric Ciotti, Nadine Morano, members of the Gaullist Republicans party)
“Meat consumption is a function of what you have in your wallet, not in your panties or your underpants… A good wine, good meat, good cheese, that is French gastronomy… What are we going to eat? Tofu and soy beans? Come on!” (Fabien Roussel, secretary general of the Communist Party)
“There’s a difference between the sexes in the way we consume meat, and people who decide to become vegetarians are mostly women… So if we want to go toward equality we have to attack virilism.” (Clémentine Autain, lawmaker with the Unbowed party)
“It’s not virilism, it’s nature.” [Julien Odoul] vowed to pursue a “Cro-Magnon diet”… (Julien Odoul, member of Marine Le Pen’s far-right National Rally)
(Roger Cohen, “Of Barbecues and Men: A Summer Storm Brews Over Virility in France,” New York Times, 9-5-22)
Pat Buchanan campaigns with a Winchester rifle in 1996. Credit… Eric Draper/Associated Press
“The American press is infatuated to the point of intoxication with ‘democracy,’ ” [Buchanan] wrote in 1991. To make his point, he compared the Marine Corps and corporations like IBM to the federal government. “Only the last is run on democratic, not autocratic, principles. Yet, who would choose the last as the superior institution?”
(Nicole Hemmer, “The Man Who Won the Republican Party Before Trump Did,” NYTimes, 9-8-22)
Statistic: Forty-nine of the 50 highest-scoring players in American football history are kickers.
“And the first ball comes off my foot like a rocket, and then the next one and the next,” he says. “I just felt like I had command over the ball, something every kicker chases.”
(Wil S. Hylton, “How Justin Tucker Became the Greatest Kicker in N.F.L. History,” NYTimes, 9-1-22)
Sports journalism can be commanding and lucid, so replete with specificity and nuanced vigor that it encroaches on poetry. Wil S. Hylton’s profile of Baltimore Ravens kicker (and Austin, Texas native) Justin Tucker is a case in point. I’ve cherry-picked some of Hylton’s lyricism into “stanzas”:
Stanza 1 Kicking is the most consequential and least understood aspect of the sport… [The place-kicker’s job] is to enter a kind of trance, as if he were the last man on earth, and perform a complex choreography of his own.
Stanza 2 He has spent the bulk of his adult life… adjusting… tinkering… perfecting… making fractional changes… He has carefully calibrated the sequence of his proximal-to-distal movements to exploit the kinematic potential of his own proportions.
Stanza 3 There’s the setup… the approach… the plant… the backswing… the follow-through… Each of these movements has its own set of customs and conventions, but none are obligatory… Anybody who’s serious about kicking knows that nobody knows that much.
Stanza 4 … The shape of a football… can be formally described as a “prolate spheroid,” which is another way of saying that it looks like a regular ball getting sucked into a vacuum hose… “The reason not many people have looked into [the aerodynamics of tumbling footballs] is because it’s a very hard problem,” says Timothy Gay, a professor of physics….
Stanza 5 “All great kickers bring a certain amount of arrogance to the table.” And yet to perfect a kick requires an almost inexhaustible reserve of humility and patience as they subject themselves to an endless barrage of punctilious criticism and microscopic correction.
I say this: Respect to the few, the finicky, the inexplicable: poets, translators and kickers.
Arabic text copied from page 10 of Gilgamesh’s Snake and Other Poems, Ghareeb Iskander, Bilingual Edition, Translated from the Arabic by John Glenday and Ghareeb Iskander, Syracuse University Press, 2015.
The transliterations bracketed below are mine. In them, tā’ marbūṭa is ẗ, and I show the lām of the article as assimilated to a following solar letter. For example: [‘ayyuhā-s-sayyidu] instead of [‘ayyuhā-l-sayyidu]. My character set, contrived to avoid digraphs, is the following:
‘ a ā i ī u ū ay aw b t ẗ ṯ j ḥ ẖ d ḏ r z s š ṣ ḍ ṭ ẓ ^ ḡ f q k l m n h w y
The text tagged “JMN” comprises my English and Spanish interpretation, and my transliteration, of the published Arabic text that’s copied in my illustration. I tag the published translation that follows it “GLENDAY” and add line numbering for ease of reference.
JMN 01 O master! (¡Maestro!) [‘ayyuhā-s-sayyidu]
02 Don’t seek eternity. (No busques la eternidad.) [lā tabḥaṯ ^ani-l-‘abadīyaẗi]
03 The stepson of unrest got there before you, (El hijastro de la inquietud te adelantó en ella,) [laqad sabaqa-ka ‘ilay-hā rabību-l-qalaqi]`
05 Take pleasure in the river that flows with blood (Recréate en el río que corre sangriento) [‘un^um bi-n-nahri-l-laḏī yajrī daman]
06 and in the eye that flows with tears. (y en el ojo que corre con lágrimas.) [wa bi-l-^ayni-l-latī tajrī dam^an]
07 Take pleasure in the end, (Recréate en el fin,) [‘un^um bi-n-nihāyaẗi]
08 in the chill of the grave, (en el frío de la tumba,) [bi-burūdaẗi-l-qabri]
09 in the gloom that the ravens glorify. (en la melancolía que los cuervos alaban.) [bi-l-waḥšaẗi-l-latī tumjidu-hā-l-ḡirbānu]
10 Don’t speak of the importance of your being alone. (No hables de la importancia de quedarte solo.) [la tatakallam ^an ‘ahammīyaẗi ‘an takūna waḥīdan]
11 They got there before you (Te adelantaron en ello) [laqad sabaqū-ka ‘ilay-hā]
12 with their hurtful hammers and desires. (con sus martillos y sus deseos nocivos.) [bi-maṭāriqi-him wa ‘amānī-himi-l-mūji^aẗi]
GLENDAY 01 Master! 02 Don’t search for everlasting life. 03 Our grandfather, Gilgamesh, 04 who was born in sadness, went there before you, 05 waded through the river flowing with blood 06 delighted in the eye that flows with tears. 07 Love the ending of things, 08 the chill of the grave 09 the strangeness the ravens sing of. 10 Don’t prattle on about needing to be alone. 11 They all went there long before you 12 following the ache and beat of their desires.
COMMENTS Lines 05 and 06 of GLENDAY hold mystery. I read the verb formed from root n-^-m as a masculine singular imperative of Form 1, with the meaning “take pleasure in” or “delight in.” Is “waded” interpretive license? Line 06 does pick up on the sense of “delighted in,” but, as with “waded,” makes it into a past tense whose subject is “Gilgamesh,” and not a command in direct address to the “master” apostrophized earlier in the poem as the writer of history, which is how I read it. Line 07 of GLENDAY seems to corroborate a parsing of ‘un^um as an imperative, because it issues a command that encompasses the meaning of na^ama: Love the ending of things.
EthicalDative 
The Nays of Texas Are Upon It
Citizens appointed by local government are policing which books held in the public library can be read by children. The local newspaper documents offending titles, along with the censor’s comments about each book. Reported summaries and excerpts of comments follow.
“Sex Is a Funny Word,” by authors Fiona Smyth and Cory Silverberg
“‘Introduce[s] ideas about sexuality, transgenderism and sexual activity… Would ‘cause confusion for children who read it and put sexual ideas that they are not mature enough to handle.’”
“Making a Baby,” by authors Rachel Greener and Clare Owen
“…Illustrations of White and racially mixed gay, lesbian and straight couples with children… ‘The pictures of naked adults and the sex act are not age appropriate for children….’”
“Queer: The Ultimate LGBTQ Guide for Teens,” by authors Kathy Belge and Marke Bieschke
“If a teen is confused about their sexuality (the book) may cause them to embrace a lifestyle they may regret… A public library should… refrain from opening doors to children that should not be opened.”
“Red: A Crayon’s Story,” by author Michael Hall
“Ideas of transgenderism [are] damaging… ‘It could twist the cognitive learning development in a child.’
“Teens and LGBT Issues,” by author Christine Wilcox
“‘…Boys who are sexually abused by men want to get rid of their genitalia because in their mind they feel like if their genitalia is gone they won’t be sexually abused again… Girls who are sexually abused often want to become boys as a way to show power so they will be feared… Why would we want this deviant behavior to mold and shape the minds of our youth?’”
(Tamara Diaz, “3 city approved library board members filed LGBTQ book complaints,” http://www.victoriaadvocate.com, 9-22-22)
(c) 2022 JMN — EthicalDative. All rights reserved