EthicalDative

Bret Stephens, conservative columnist:

Imagine a TV ad from a moderate Democrat like Ohio’s Tim Ryan or Virginia’s Abigail Spanberger that goes something like this:

“I believe in the Second Amendment. But not for this guy,” followed by a picture of the Tucson, Ariz., mass murderer Jared Lee Loughner, “or this guy” — a picture of Aurora, Colo., mass murderer James Holmes, “or this guy” — a picture of Newtown, Conn., mass murderer Adam Lanza.

It would continue: “I also believe in the right to own firearms responsibly for hunting and self-defense. But not for this” — a picture of the scene outside the Uvalde school, “or this” — a picture of the scene from the Buffalo grocery store, “or this” — scenes from the Parkland massacre.

And it could conclude: “Justice Robert Jackson once told us that the Bill of Rights cannot become a suicide pact. That includes the Second Amendment. We can protect your guns while keeping them out of the hands of crazy and dangerous people by using common-sense background checks, 21-years-of-age purchasing requirements, three-day waiting periods and mental-health exams. It’s not about denying your constitutional rights. It’s so your children come home from school alive.

(The Conversation: “There Has to Be a Tipping Point on Guns, Right?” NYTimes, 6-6-22)

Matthew McConaughey, actor and Uvalde native:

(White House press briefing, YouTube, 6-7-22)

(c) 2022 JMN — EthicalDative. All rights reserved

A comment to a recent post here (https://ethicaldative.com/2022/06/01/pledge-of-resistance/) states:

“People kill people. Not guns, cars or anything else. People need help and they don’t get it. Our society decided that inclusion is more important than helping people and/ or making others safe from them.”

The comment alludes to a grave weakness of Texas government. It’s true that mental illness and weapons of mass destruction are a bad mix. After the Uvalde massacre on May 24, 2022, Texas governor Greg Abbot spoke about the importance of dealing with mental illness. Less than two months before that, however, he cut more than $200 million from the Texas commission that oversees mental health services in the state. According to the 2022 State of Mental Health in America report, Texas ranks fourth in the U.S. for prevalence of mental illness, but last for access to mental health care. At a press conference a day after the massacre, Abbott conceded that authorities were unaware of any criminal record or history of mental illness that could have flagged the 18-year-old Uvalde killer as a potential threat.

Nearly 10 years before Uvalde, in late 2012, 16 first graders at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Connecticut hid in their class bathroom. A 20-year-old male fired more than 80 rounds from a Bushmaster semiautomatic rifle into the 4½ by 3½-foot space, killing 15 of the children. The killer murdered 28 people at the school in all. One encounters variants of the argument that blaming guns for killing people is like blaming pencils for spelling errors. In this dismissive analogy the “errors” are human corpses.

A more reasonable conservative voice offers a glimmer of hope for reaching a modest middle ground:

There’s a future where America’s gun-ownership rate is as high as ever, where our schools still look like schools rather than airport security lines and where 18-year-olds under a demoniac shadow face meaningful obstacles to arming themselves for terrorism. Let’s try living there, and see what happens next. [Ross Douthat]

Sources:

Kyle R. Cotton, “Trey Ganem’s Edna shop donates custom caskets to Uvalde shooting victims,” victoriaadvocate.com, 6-1-22.
Frank Bruni, “Gov. Greg Abbott Has a Lot of Nerve,” NYTimes, 6-2-22.
Zach Despart, “This Time Gov. Greg Abbott has few suggestions on how the state might prevent future mass shootings,” www.texastribune.org, 5-25-22.
Elizabeth Williamson, “From Sandy Hook to Uvalde, the Violent Images Never Seen,” NYTimes, 5-30-22.
Ross Douthat, “The Simplest Response to School Shootings,” NYTimes, 6-1-2022.

(c) 2022 JMN — EthicalDative. All rights reserved

I pledge resistance to the flag of the AR-15s of America, and to the mythology for which it stands. Wounded nation under Fox, indefensible, with liberty and justice for some.

In the summer of 2008, the Supreme Court decided District of Columbia v. Heller, in which the court held for the first time that the Second Amendment protected an individual right to gun ownership… Justice Scalia’s majority opinion held that [it] protected an individual right to keep a usable handgun at home… Justice Stevens argued that [its] protections extended only to firearm ownership in conjunction with service in a “well-regulated militia,” in the words of the Second Amendment… Nothing in Heller casts doubt on the permissibility of background check laws… Heller also gives the government at least some leeway to restrict the kinds of firearms that can be purchased… Most of the obstacles to gun regulations are political and policy based, not legal… because of an unduly expansive reading of Heller.

(Kate Shaw and John Bash, “We Clerked for Justices Scalia and Stevens. America Is Getting Heller Wrong,” NYTimes, 5-31-22)

…A violent society ought… to regard its handiwork… I myself would like politicians to view [the Uvalde photographs]: to look — really look — at the shattered face of what was previously a child and to then contemplate the bewildered terror of her last moments on earth. But that would not mean that the jig is up. People, not photographs, create political change….

(Susie Linfield, “Should We Be Forced to See Exactly What an AR-15 Does to a 10-Year-Old?” NYTimes, 3-31-22)

(c) 2022 JMN — EthicalDative. All rights reserved