Rollicking Chin Wag Introduces ‘Mumble Rap’

The New York Times recorded interview with Earl Sweatshirt was a freewheeling romp by a voluble cohort of cognoscenti. High spirits prevailed. The three-way session was suffused with knowing guffaws, spicy vernacular and poignant insider allusion. For the hip-hop-curious outsider listening in, it felt like sniffing someone else’s delicious picnic and longing for a taste of the goodies.

I’ve often meditated on what role the lyrics play in pop music, fretting over my inability to understand the words of many songs. I’m talking about the vocalizations of well nigh every front man or woman of every rock group I’ve ever listened to — I don’t mean only Elton John and Robert Plant. (Paul Simon is an exception.)

I settled resignedly into the notion that the singers’ voices were simply another instrument in the combo; that what they uttered were musical noises, as notes are noises, and unencumbered with conventional denotative freight; they were not units of spoken communication at all. If the singers weren’t bothered for their noises to reach me as words, I wasn’t bothered to decode those noises other than tonally and acoustically. It was all about the melody, the moves, the beat, the “wall of sound,” baby.

In his interview, Earl dropped a remark that has turned my modus vivendi with pop garble on its head:

I definitely want to always be expanding my linguistic capabilities. If you’re in 2025 complaining about mumble rap — probably racist. If you haven’t processed that different people talk different ways, like, why are you not trying to aspire to learn new things? Like Boomhauer, his homies know what he’s talking about.

Yikes. Message received and taken under advisement. Processing like crazy here. 

I’d never heard the term “mumble rap” before, but I ask myself, “Have I been bitching unfairly about ‘mumble rock’ all the while?” Maybe I need to cultivate better aural literacy in genres that eschew punctilious enunciation, in like manner as I’ve done in studying the different ways foreigners use their tongues, attuning my ear to novel sounds, unaccustomed rhythms, runaway velocities. Putting in extra effort, damn it. I’m up for it. Never stop aspiring to learn new things, I say. (Also, I need to reflect on how the author of a book on hip-hop lyrics hangs out on genius.com curating the written signature of an oral genre.)

Rap, if not pop, I surmise, wants to be experienced as language on top of music. In casual contact with the genre, I’ve encountered references to a performer’s “flow” — the stream of speech. Pains are taken to create rhyme. These two characteristics alone suggest that its lyrics be treated as disclosure and narrative rather than highly cadenced, quasi-melodic, sonic gesture. Chant comes to mind, an intriguing and time-honored analog.

(c) 2025 JMN — EthicalDative. All rights reserved

Posted in Commentary | Tagged , , | 5 Comments

Absurdity Muddled With Beauty: Insouciant!


Man Ray’s “Le violon d’Ingres,” 1924. The showstopper at the Met, purchased at auction for about $12.4 million, shows Man Ray’s lover, Kiki de Montparnasse (born Alice Prin). Credit… Man Ray 2015 Trust/Artists Rights Society(ARS), NY/ADAGP, Paris 2025; via Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York. [New York Times caption and illustration]

Muddling is when you gently and lovingly release aromatic oils from fruits and herbs.

“I have finally freed myself from the sticky medium of paint, and am working directly with light itself.”


(Man Ray, 1922)

In French, the title [“Violon d’Ingres] is an idiom for a hobby, derived from the story that the great painter Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres prized his amateur violin playing as highly as his art.

To make his image, Man Ray photographed Kiki de Montparnasse from behind, nude to just below the waist and wearing a turban, a pose that Ingres had used in the painting known as “The Valpinçon Bather,” on view in the Louvre. On Kiki’s lower back on the print, Man Ray drew the f-holes of a violin in black ink.

Afterward, he had another idea. He enlarged the print of Kiki in the darkroom and masked it with a sheet of paper or cardboard on which he had cut two f-holes. Then he flashed the light again, so that the shapes were burned black, to make what he called “a combination of a photo and a rayograph.”

… Along with an ingenious melding of techniques, he had transposed a verbal pun into visual reality. In its beauty and absurdity, “Le Violon d’Ingres” encapsulates, arguably better than any other artwork, the insouciant wit of Surrealism…

(Arthur Lubow, “Man Ray’s Mysteries, in Glorious Bloom at the Met,” New York Times, 9-6-25)

(c) 2025 JMN — EthicalDative. All rights reserved

Posted in Quotations | Tagged , | 2 Comments

The Rivers That Reaches for the Ocean

“You’re only given one little spark of madness. You mustn’t lose it.”

(Robin Williams, quoted by Mitch Teemley)

The Guadalupe reaches for the ocean.
The Pedernales reaches for the ocean.
The Rio Grande reaches for the ocean.
The Colorado reaches for the ocean.
The San Jacinto reaches for the ocean.

The Brazos doesn’t reaches for the ocean.
The Devils doesn’t reaches for the ocean.
The Pecos doesn’t reaches for the ocean.
The Neches doesn’t reaches for the ocean.
The Sulphur doesn’t reaches for the ocean.
The Cypress doesn’t reaches for the ocean.

The Red, the Sabine,
The Nueces, the Lavaca, the Trinity,
The Canadian, the San Antonio
Doesn’t reaches for the ocean.

(c) 2025 JMN — EthicalDative. All rights reserved

Posted in Anthology | Tagged , , , , , , , | 9 Comments

This Is Now (Again)

“He’s also piercingly smart about his place as a white observer in a Black art form.”


(Jayson Greene, on Daniel Levin Becker)

Before you-know-who was president, I encountered something called Twitter, ran with it for maybe six weeks. That was in what — oh-nine? I’d been reading about hip-hop in The New Yorker, a starkly pale conveyance into the zone some would say, but well written by I forget who. The rappers’ go-by’s intrigued me: X goes by the name Y, performs with Z who goes by the name A.

Going by names held charm for me. An ecstasy of gnarly monikers. I had fun with it in a couple of tweets. Said something like “I’m so-and-so and go by High Plains Drifter.” Bad idea. Somebody went shut the fuck up. I may have been, what they say in football, offside. I dropped Twitter like a hot potato.

One good thing came of the putdown; I bumped into Earl Sweatshirt. Not for any gainful purpose, just that the name was genially ripe, had staying power. Wouldn’t you know? Earl is in my head again via The Times: 

Often, Earl has appeared to be hiding in plain view, an accidental superstar trying to stay grounded. Over the past decade, he’s been one of the most visible makers of lo-fi, subterranean, lyrically abstruse rap music, a style that has both earned him a fervent following of connoisseurs and kept casual peekers at bay.

Look, I read poetry — more of it than I understand. Anything “lyrically abstruse” is catnip for this pussy. If only someone called Earl’s songs something like “muddily intricate and knotty.” 

After crash-landing into the spotlight, he’s been inching his way out of it… one muddily intricate and knotty song at a time.

That does it, my heart leapt. Memo to High Plains Drifter: There’s a book* by a guy. Buy. Read. Learn. Listen. And zip it.

*What’s Good: Notes on Rap and Language, by Daniel Levin Becker (City Lights Books, 2022).

(c) 2025 JMN — EthicalDative. All rights reserved

Posted in Commentary | Tagged , , , , | 4 Comments

THERE Be Dragons — Blue Ones!

A photograph of blue dragon was posted on the Facebook page of the Guardamar del Segura police department. Policia Local Guardamar. [New York Times caption and illustration]

“We still don’t know exactly what we’re dealing with here… But given the warming of the Mediterranean,… we’re not ruling out that in the coming years we will once again confront situations that we’ve never dealt with.”


(José Luis Sáez, mayor of Guardamar del Segura, Spain)

The Glaucus atlanticus, or blue dragon, is a sea slug that packs “one of the most ferocious stings in the animal world.” It can feed on jellyfish and the venomous Portuguese man-of-war. Typically found in warm tropical waters, blue dragons have been washing up at a concerning level on Mediterranean beaches and in the Canary Islands.

“DANGER, Blue Dragon. Danger to swimmers for its poisonous bite. Swimming not advised.”
A warning poster from the government of Haría, on the Canary Islands, about the blue dragons. Credit… Haría city hall. [New York Times caption and illustration — translation by JMN]

The Mediterranean is among the fastest-warming bodies of water in the world, with water temperatures hitting record highs in June and July this year, according to Mercator Ocean International.

(Jonathan Wolfe, “‘We Are All Shocked’: Warming Waters Bring a Stinging Sea Slug to Spain’s Coasts,” New York Times, 8-28-25)

(c) 2025 JMN — EthicalDative. All rights reserved

Posted in Quotations | Tagged | 5 Comments

Mission Accomplished: The Zone Is Flooded

After Degas.

“This facility is supposed to house non-violent offenders… Human trafficking is a violent crime.”


(Julie Howell, inmate of Bryan Federal Prison Camp)

The site of the ancient toilet where the Jordan CodeX was found, known to antiquity buffs as “the zone,” is submerged now by Alaskan runoff. For what it’s worth, a dying peep from the black hole swallowing the truth star is emitted by the codeX’s “jingle.” Its text was hacked into re-existence with blockchain tools by a crack team under the direction of Dr. Vladimir Potemkin, professor of alternative history at the storied Russian-American Institute of Soviet Sciences in Anchorage.

Read the CodeX’s explosive “Prologue” here.

“Jingle”
The sultan of sleaze with his pandering bawd
Did people the mansions with underage goods,
To be ogled, debauched, violated and pawed
By the randy, philandering, fatuous dudes.

The perv got arrested and clapped in a cell,
Then hanged by the neck with a sheet from his bed.
The sorry event is suspicious as hell,
And has many a citizen scratching their head.

So what’s to be made of his myrmidon’s fate,
The procuress of children for indecent uses?
Her master required them his “aches” to abate.
She delivered them to him with sinister ruses.

Does she aim to procure a get-out-of-jail card?
Her crimes to be pardoned, her sentence to void?
It’s the sign of the soul of a moral retard!
Mail your thoughts and your prayers to the girls she destroyed!

(c) 2025 JMN — EthicalDative. All rights reserved

Posted in Anthology | Tagged | 2 Comments

How Do You Say ‘Drill, Baby, Drill!’ in Putonghua?


New York Times image taken from here.

“Chinese scholars… absolutely dominate research in the following fields: materials science, chemistry, engineering, computer science, the environment and ecology, agricultural science, physics and math.”


(David Brooks)

China cheers cheeky America’s fossil fuelish folly. Here’s why:

China leads global production in
— steel
— aluminum
— shipbuilding
— batteries
— solar power
— electric vehicles
— wind turbines
— drones
— 5G equipment
— consumer electronics
— active pharmaceutical ingredients
— bullet trains.

The very wellfare of warfare is on the line, for chrissake. Place your bets: China or US ASAP?

Never fear. An old saying I made up is:

Governments can’t find money for much of anything until it’s time to find it for making war. Then Katy bar the door, the funds are magicked up like wildfire roaring down a bone dry, scrub-choked California canyon. 

I no it’s wordy for an old saying, but practice it a bit and you’ll be parroting it in know time. <wink>

(c) 2025 JMN — EthicalDative. All rights reserved

Posted in Commentary | Tagged | 6 Comments

Does the ‘Jordan’ Codex Shed Light on the Elapse? Dispute Rages.

After Degas.

“Whatever we may ultimately learn about Epstein, it will be sad and sordid, a story of people getting hurt and of people getting away with hurting them.”


(Peter C. Baker)

The last half of first-quarter Century XXI CE bequeathed much fake history to its successors. Today, scholars scour the record in search of ephemera that may afford a glimpse of what actually happened. A scrap of paper excavated from the environs of an ancient toilet has been studied extensively. The badly damaged typescript is thought to be rhymed doggerel in dactylic meter. What’s referred to as its “prologue” arguably has been deciphered. The rest, known to scholars as the “jingle,” is riddled with lacunae. 

Jordan scholarship has focused on establishing what are thought to be the end rhymes. The version published by Carruthers, Bane and Triffling embeds what’s legible of the document in a metric scheme which deploys bracketed diereses (<…>) as syllabic placeholders. Tonic syllables are in boldface (<…>). It was hoped that prosodic specialists might assist in fleshing out more of the document’s content.

Experts differ as to what, if anything, the codex may contribute to our knowledge of the elapse.

“Prologue”
When the mighty Jordan [River?] of justice
Is perverted [diverted] to pestilential [“puking”] tributaries [creeks?],
Toady [slang?] sinkholes [swine lagoons?] reek of slime [or “slipperiness”].

“Jingle”
The <…><…> of sleaze <…><…> pandering bawd
<…><…><…><…> mansions <…> underaged goods,
To be <…><…>, <…> <…>, <…>, <…> <…> <…> and pawed
<…><…><…> <…>, philandering, <…> <…> <…> dudes.

The <…> got <…><…><…> <…><…> <…> the klink
<…> hanged <…><…><…><…><…> sheet <…><…> bed.
How <…><…><…><…> <…>? The <…> <…> <…> think
That <…><…><…><…> playboy set <…><…><…> dead!

And <…><…><…><…><…><…> <…><…> procuress
<…> fourteen-year-olds <…><…> <…> <…> “massages” —
<…><…> alcahueta <…><…> <…> <…> foulness,
<…> <…> <…> queen bee <…><…><…> <…> <…> lodges?

<…><…><…><…><…><…><…> get-out-of-jail card!
<…><…><…><…> pardoned, <…><…><…> <…> void!
<…><…><…><…> soul <…><…> moral retard.
<…><…> thoughts and <…><…><…><…> girls <…> destroyed.

(c) 2025 JMN — EthicalDative. All rights reserved

Posted in Anthology | Tagged , , | 3 Comments

Hill Country, Texas Camper’s Song


Torque is force applied over distance. Transitivity is force applied by a verb to its complement. A directly transitive verb has accusative torque; it slams directly into its object. Wham-Bam. A non-transitive verb influences its complement via a preposition; it has genitive torque. Wham-prep-Bam. Languages diverge flagrantly on transitivity. That’s how they roll: divergently. Transiting between English and Arabic is an adventure in navigation. If you sail by the seat of your pants, you end up where there be dragons. You gotta steer by your Hans Wehr dictionary, close to the wind.

Down I lay me now to sleep and pray
For come who might to whats-it in the sky.
Not dead before I wake may I be found.
To sleep and pray now down I do me lay.
The ocean’s mighty large and wet, they say.
Please find it, Guadalupe. By and by
Shall I lay me down to sleep and pray
For come who might to whats-it in the sky.

(c) 2025 JMN — EthicalDative. All rights reserved

Posted in Anthology | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

‘A Wild and Capacious Art’


When we beseech we implore screechingly. The act of beseeching is melded with a posture of self abasement in the form 5 Arabic verb taḍarra^u. The Wehr definitions include implore, beg and entreat. Also, to humiliate oneself, which in English connotative usage isn’t the same as having humility or being humble, is it? Does a person in authority demand groveling in exchange for favor? 7.55

“Poetry belongs to all who write, read, sing and sign it.”

(Adrian Matejka)

”A wild and capacious art” is how Adrian Matejka describes it. The editor of Poetry knows whereof he speaks, though I would hazard that other art forms besides poetry — opera, square dance, zither music — “belong” to their respective buffs, too. It’s an orotund assertion with wide application — the opposite of exclusionary.

Poetry spurns elitism, Matejka writes: 

It is “for the people,” as June Jordan taught us — despite the exclusionary positions of some critics. This communal posture is what makes poetry open to anyone who wants to engage with it as a writer or as a reader… 

Who doesn’t want to be enthused by a communal posture? In the rarefied world of poetry readership, two’s company, three’s a community. Widening the scope of what counts as poetry helps:

Some of the great poet-emcees like Rakim and Chuck D introduced me to the concept of poetry… They showed me… that poetry’s habits are universal and transferrable across mediums… It is malleable, transcending the strictures of its particular, versified container. 

Ryan Ruby* states the case less floridly:

All concepts are vague, but at present there is no consensus as to what poetry even is, how to define a poem, or who counts as a poet, which is perhaps why we have settled, a little uneasily, on a manifestly circular definition of poetry: a poem is whatever a person recognized as a poet says is a poem.

* Context Collapse: A Poem Containing a History of Poetry

(c) 2025 JMN — EthicalDative. All rights reserved

Posted in Anthology | Tagged , , | 5 Comments